The Huffington Post Gay Marriage
Log In | Sign Up | January 6, 2009
Spread Awareness - Stumble this Big News Page



Links From Digg, Delicious, and Google Blogsearch

Lee Stranahan: Why Are Gay Marriage Advocates Not Defending Polyamory?



Comments
124
Pending Comments
4
Post Comment

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next › Last » (6 pages total)
- gary47290 See Profile I'm a Fan of gary47290 permalink

Why aren't gay people "supporting" polyamory? Because polyamory / group marriage /whatever you call it raises a host of difficult legal and social issues that must be addressed before any discussion can start for whether the US should legally recognize polyamorous relationships.

Marriage establishes kinship. As in "next of kin" the person who can speak for you when you can't, who inherits from you, etc.

In a polyamorous world, who is "next of kin"?

What happens legally if person A , B and C have a legal relationship, then C wants out of A. Where does that leave B and C?

Polygamy has historically been abusive to women, because it involves a powerful man and multiple powerless women. The recent scandals with Jeffs and the Fundy LDS sects in the Southwest do not suggest this is any different in the 21st century than it was in Biblical times.

I could go on, but the you get the idea. The poly proponents need to solve these problems first. On the other hand, no legal changes except the pairings allowed need be made to enact marriage equality for same sex couples. Marriage equality for dyads is not redefining marriage. Multiple marriage does.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:19 PM on 01/06/2009
- Baldran See Profile I'm a Fan of Baldran permalink

Being bisexual doesn't mean having multiple sexual partners. Being bisexual means that you are attracted to both genders, and can therefore form a romantic or sexual relationship with someone of either gender. Bi people don't practice or seek polyamorous relationships any more than anyone else, which I though would have been obvious by this point in time. Unfortunately, it seems like some people still can't get over their stereotypes, whether they be gay or straight.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:53 PM on 01/06/2009
- RobinSeattle See Profile I'm a Fan of RobinSeattle permalink

Lee, I think government should get out of the marriage business altogether. Why should government be a shadow partner in an intimate relationship between consenting adults? It's ridiculous. Our divorce laws (especially as regards alimony, which is a totally anti-feminist construct) are at least two generations out of date now as well.

Issues such as child support and divvying up community property can be determined as matters of contract law where the partners negotiate in good faith before the sprog is born or the home is bought, like a business partnership, and not the current exploitative framework where somebody gets taken to the cleaners in a divorce proceeding and the lawyers involved make a killing.

I'm totally fine with polyamory. Whatever gets you through a weekend. But Government needs to butt out of people's private lives and the churches can do whatever they want in terms of who they will hold ceremonies for without all this sturm and drang over government giving special breaks to married heterosexuals but not to committed gays and lesbian partners.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:52 PM on 01/06/2009
- smithshaw08 See Profile I'm a Fan of smithshaw08 permalink

I support marriage between consenting adults. That could be gay marriage, polyamory, polygamy as long as everyone is of legal age, willing & able. This does not include farm animals or children. They can not consent to a marriage contract. If you are going to have more than one wife at a time, please do not use the welfare system to support your harem.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:32 PM on 01/06/2009